• Site Navigation

    • Customer Testimonials
    • Press Reviews
    • Our Cookie Dough
    • Order Outrageous Cookie Dough!
    • Current Retail Locations
    • Cookie Dough Fundraising with FatBoy
    • Corporate Gifts
  • Recent Blog Posts

    • Fatboy in Columbus Circle, NYC
    • Samples @ Fairway – Paramus, NJ
    • Local Day – West Hartford, CT
    • Whole Foods – Montclair, NJ
    • Whole Foods – Madison, NJ
  • Blog Archives


Follow FatBoy's Cookie Dough on Twitter!


Follow FatBoy's Cookie Dough on Facebook!


Follow FatBoy's Cookie Dough on YouTube!

Easy, tasty cookies

Easy,  tasty  cookies 

Reviewed by: Consumer Reports, August 2007

Good news for the time-pressed: Chocolate-chip cookies made with store-bought dough can taste almost homemade.

Our trained panelists tasted cookies made from seven preformed cookie doughs, frozen or refrigerated, and cookies made from scratch using the Nestlé Toll House recipe. The best of the bunch, all from frozen doughs, tasted close to cookies made from scratch. They had a mix of buttery, caramelized, and other cookielike flavors, plus chocolatey chunks or chips that were especially big in dough from Omaha Steaks and Fat Boy.

Lowest-rated was refrigerated Nestlé dough, which made cookies bearing little resemblance to those from the recipe. They didn’t taste fresh-baked, did have a bit of old-fat taste, and were smaller than most. But even the lowest-rated from dough were better than typical store-bought packaged cookies.

Calories per cookie range from 100 to 150; fat, from 5 to 8 grams. They basically correspond to cookie size, listed below.

CR’s take. If you crave a sweet treat but want to avoid mixing and some cleanup, you’ll be a smart cookie if you try one of the very good doughs. Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods are available in those stores; Omaha Steaks and Fat Boy are sold online or over the phone. David’s, rated good, is at their website.

If you want to tell Aunt Millie you used her recipe, it’ll be our secret.

Ratings

In order of overall quality.

Product Per cookie Frozen
Cost* Size (g)
VERY GOOD Complex flavors, fresh-baked taste, chocolatey chips.
Trader Joe’s Chunky CR Best Buy 22¢ 28 ✓
Omaha Steaks Chunky 33¢ 26 ✓
Fat Boy Cookie Company Outrageous Chunk 59¢ 35 ✓
Whole Foods Chip 33¢ 31 ✓
GOOD No fresh-baked impression, closer to packaged cookies.
David’s Preformed Chunk 36¢ 28 ✓
Pillsbury Ready to Bake with Hershey Chips 16¢ 21
Nestlé Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookies 17¢ 21
*Shipping is included except for Omaha Steaks, where costs vary with promotions.

Other Press Reviews of our Outrageous Cookie Dough...

Fresh-baked treats sans the trans fat »

Fatboy's a Hit with Phil Lempert »

ABC News Now & Fatboy's »

FatBoy’s Outrageous Cookie Dough »

Supermarket Standouts: Best Brands, Best Values »

YUMMIES, Fat Boy Baking »

DOUGH, BOY! »


Our Cookies | Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough | Cranberry Nut Cookie Dough | Dutch Chocolate Chunk Walnut Cookie Dough
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Dough | Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough | White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie Dough
Ingredients | Reviews | Ordering Info | Track Orders | Retail Locations | Fundraising | Wholesale Info | Corporate Gifts | Contact
Copyright © 2010 The FatBoy Cookie Company. All rights reserved.   Website designed & hosted by Zoinks! Graphics: Website Design.